The Giada at Home star’s classic tiramisu is, well, traditional, and includes six egg yolks, sugar, mascarpone cheese, espresso, dark rum, packaged ladyfinger cookies, and bittersweet chocolate.

Jon Shook and Vinny Dotolo serve rainbow cookies at their Italian American cafe, Jon & Vinny’s. “Anytime I see one, I order it,” Dotolo says, adding that it’s his favorite cookie.