The best pizza-makers consider every ingredient and prepare them in a way that lets them be their best selves. Pineapple—and any other ingredient you choose to pair with pineapple—is no different.

Pineapple on PIZZA? NOOOO!! What is even happening to me? No, I haven’t been brainwashed (or kidnapped) BUT I have been challenged by SO many of you to eat pineapple on my pizza so I have given in.

“This is what pineapple pizza should taste like,” I texted her. “I want to eat all the fruit on pizza now.” Since then, I’ve been pretty successful in that effort.

Carlo Longo's hilarious reaction to his fiancée asking if she can order pineapple on a pizza while in a restaurant in Italy has amassed over 1.5 million likes.